COMMENTARY BY STEVE BARLOW
As social media lit up recently over a report that Nonnewaug and Lakeview want to leave the Berkshire League for the Naugatuck Valley League, one thought kept echoing in my head: Be careful what you wish for.
Rumors of Nonnewaug’s interest in the NVL have been bouncing around the hills for months. Two weeks ago, John McKenna’s Litchfield.bz website reported Lakeview athletic director Jim Parker told his Board of Education that Nonnewaug had applied to the NVL and that their school should, too.
Actually, Parker was premature. The NVL hasn’t received any applications for expansion – yet. For now, BL athletic directors are discussing the future and schools are considering their options. Stay tuned.
The reasons Nonnewaug and Lakeview, the only Class M schools in the small-school BL, want to leave are familiar: declining enrollments, too many noncompetitive games, a shortage of JV teams, and JV squads masquerading as varsity teams, to name a few. The same reasons prompted Lewis Mills eight years ago to move to the Central Connecticut Conference.
And how has that worked out for the Spartans?
Their soccer teams, as expected, have thrived against the superior competition. The basketball teams have fared better than anticipated. The baseball and softball teams have been mostly competitive. Football is enjoying its first winning season in the CCC this fall. Overall, the step up, while producing a lot more losses, hasn’t been the bloodbath some fans feared.
But one day last winter, while covering a basketball game at Mills, I happened to study the gym wall where banners are hung for conference and state championships. Plenty of BL titles adorn the wall and many others date back to the old Northwest Conference days.
Absent are any from the CCC.
That’s because Mills, the second-smallest school in the CCC, hasn’t won any league titles in any sports since joining in 2019. The Spartans are in a whole different world now.
Mills’ boys soccer team, which dominated in the BL, only qualified for the eight-team CCC playoffs for the first time this fall. The Spartans get to host South Windsor, the third-seeded team in Class LL, in the first round. Even when Mills won the Class M state title in 2023, it didn’t win the league.
Mills’ girls soccer team, which dominated in the BL, didn’t qualify for the eight-team CCC playoffs this fall despite currently being ranked second in Class S. Even when Mills won the Class M state title in 2024, it didn’t win the league.
In other, so-called minor sports, Mills has even less chance to be king or queen of the conference. In seasons past, I have checked the Mills runners’ times at the CCC cross country meets. Sometimes, they would have been good enough to win, place or show at the BL championships. In the CCC, they were lucky to finish in the top 20 or 30.
The Spartans’ coaches and athletes have adjusted. They now focus on how the CCC will prepare them for the state tournaments. Indeed, when I suggested once to a Mills coach that a state title is easier to win than a CCC title, he readily agreed.
But only a handful of teams win state titles each year. The Spartans have essentially been denied the joy of a league championship. While it may be easier to win, we’ve yet to see anyone who wasn’t excited to claim a BL title. Parents still crowd around for photos of their kids with the trophy.
In an eight-team league (which once upon a time was the standard size for high school conferences), winning a title is simply easier than in a megaconference. While the NVL isn’t the CCC – there are plenty of Class M schools – it already has double the membership of the BL.
And there’s one essential question: How big does the NVL, now 15 members strong, want to be?
When a merger of the two leagues died nine years ago, two NVL athletic directors told me: “We don’t want to drive up there.” Understandable (especially now with $4 gasoline). But is Woodbury close enough? Is Bantam too far? How about Winsted?
Not every BL school may want to join the NVL. In years past, Northwestern has had informal chats with North Central Connecticut Conference schools about joining their league. The Highlanders routinely play neighbors Granby and Canton in nonleague games and would culturally be a smooth fit.
Whither the other BL schools? A really good question. If the BL fell apart, Housatonic might have to look across the border, for Pete’s sake. It’s closer to schools in Massachusetts and New York than to anyone in Connecticut. Shepaug already plays several South-West Conference teams in various sports, but probably wouldn’t desire a steady diet of them.
Or would the NCCC open its doors to any and all orphans? In 2015, it was willing to accept seven small schools from the Eastern Connecticut Conference, including faraway Stonington, before the applicants decided to stay put. Stonington is 50 miles from the nearest NCCC member, Coventry. By contrast, Shepaug and Housatonic are 30-35 miles from Canton.
The distances in the 12-team NCCC are far greater than in the NVL, but if the BL went en masse, it might be possible to mitigate that issue through divisions. The same would be true if the NVL added a Berkshire division, although that’s the merger idea that was already rejected.
Regardless of what happens before the Dec. 1 deadline for applications, let’s hope the BL schools decide to hang together, rather than spiraling into an every-man-for-himself scramble. No school should be left behind.
A few years ago, after a titanic Shepaug-Nonnewaug battle in the BL boys basketball final, Rick Wilson and I walked out of the electrified Thomaston gym talking about how lucky we were to have our jobs. We had witnessed an instant classic. Whether we ever see another is now up in the air.
Be careful what you wish for. We won’t know what we’ve lost until it’s gone.
Steve Barlow has covered the Berkshire League for more than 25 years.
